David Mackin offers a little insight into the Matchmaking process.
(Warning: He plugs Joshua Harris's book I Kissed Dating Goodbye. Which, in my opinion, is one of the most ridiculous books ever written. From personal experience, married people love this book. Single people, not so much.)
(Warning Update: Don't let the "plug" dissuade you from reading the entire post. Mr. Mackin truly has some interesting thoughts regarding matchmaking and dating in general.)
Match-making Pastors:
In about 1974, Sam Poe, a young pastor in Kelso-Longview, called Chris Stenson (name changed). He said that he wanted to get married and asked chris if he had any godly women at his Church/School that he could recommend to him. Chris introduced him to a spiritual and intelligent student named Marlene. Sam met Marlene, fell in love, and, as far as I could tell when I saw them several years ago at Arlan Askew’s church (Westside Vineyard), they have been living happily ever serving God together in the ministry. Thanks to Chris Stenson.
Match-breaking Pastors:
In about 1975, I traveled to Brazil and Jamaica with Steven Beaver (name changed). At that time, both of us were dating. Steven was dating Lois Lane (name changed) and I was dating Trisha (name changed). While in Jamaica, I remember us both taking some special time to pick out some dress materials that we thought Lois and Trisha would like. After we arrived back home, Chris Stenson called me into his office. He told me that since I had been dating Trisha for about a couple of years, that it was time that I had to make up my mind as to whether I wanted to marry her or not. If I wasn’t ready to marry her, then he told me that he wanted me to break up. Some time after my conversation with Chris, I remember sitting in Trisha’s living room (her parents lived right across the street from the church), with tears pouring down my cheeks, I told her as I was pounding my hand on the arm of the chair: I am not ready to get married right now; maybe later, but not right now. But, I have to break up with you because Chris has told me that if I’m not ready to propose to you, then he wants me to end it. She didn’t have much to say, and then I left.
Match-making Alternatives:
Some pastors have dumped the dating model for the young people in their local churches and have adopted the courting model. The essence of the courting model is based on the belief that young people are not wise enough to make their own life mate choices. When a man is interested in a young woman, he must observe her in groups as much as he can, and, if interested in pursuing her, he must go to the woman’s father first and ask him if he can court his daughter. This means begin down the road to marriage. If accepted, the man begins to do everything with the girl’s family and does not really spend time alone with her (lest they get tempted). In my view, the courting model has both an upside and a downside. The upsides are: (1) healthy family emphasis (2) possibly less temptation and (3) saving one’s daughters from multiple heartbreaks. The downsides are: (1) the guy and girl don’t really get to know each other since they are hardly ever allowed to spend time together (2) how does this work with older singles? (3) how does this work when both sets of parents aren’t into the courting model? (4) how does this not just become another form of arranged marriage by two families in the same local church eager to see their children wed? (If you want to read more about the positive sides of the courting model see: I Kissed Dating Good-bye and Boy Meets Girl by Joshua Harris.)
Match-making in the Local Church Culture:
I loved the movie, The Firm, starring Tom Cruise. In the movie, Tom plays an intelligent graduate fresh out of law school who gets unknowingly hired by a prestigious law firm that is run by the mob. He doesn’t see the mob connections at first because he likes the money and the prestige. While a representative of the firm is giving Tom a tour of his new office, Tom asks what the firm’s view is on the partners starting families. The representative says without hesitation that the firm loves and greatly encourages children and families. (I think that the local church acts like this firm much of the time. They push marriage very strongly so that young people are saved from temptation (oops! adultery is a huge problem today), and all of the main leaders on their staff are “safely married.” Plus, with being married and kids shortly on the way, a local church firm can have more tentacles on a person that if s/he was single and “rootless.”) More roots = more control. This part of the movie reminded me of when I was a young man at church, apparently showing some form of leadership calling on my life to those “over me.” One day Frank told me that he felt my hesitation in getting married was from my Catholic background and my wanting to be a celibate priest when I was growing up. Rick Johnston, a former head of my church's counseling department, asked me one day: “David, how do you see women? Are they just like looking at dogs to you or what?” (In other words, do you have normal sexual desires toward women?) When I did get engaged, we went to one of the married elders for pre-marital counseling. Honestly, it was a joke. I felt that we were just going through a form – they were so excited to see us “engaged!” As it turned out, I did get married in the same year as I was hired as a church college teacher. How ironic! Unfortunately, the marriage lasted only 15 years at which time my wife filed for a divorce. As I look back, my first wife and I didn’t really take the time to get to know each other as we should have. (If you’re interested in a book that I found extremely helpful in finding a more compatible mate my second time around see: Date or Soul Mate? by Neil Clark Warren.)